兩個都是人工智能,都可以對話,但是不同。
Perplexity對來者的提問,會提出答案和答案的資料來源,收到答案的人可以追溯資料來源加以核對正確性,並且可以自行判斷Perplexity使用的證據來源是否具權威性來決定答案是否可靠。
反之,CHATGPT比較像是聊天的對象,對於CHATGPT所提出的答案一定要抱持質疑的態度,因為幾次的經驗會發現GHATGPT蠻會瞎掰的,表面煞有其事,卻不實,頗像鐵獅玉玲瓏中的許效舜,圓融有趣(哈哈~~)!不過一但你可以提出證據確鑿的反駁資料,CHATGPT會像一個有風度的學者立即道歉,並立即提出新的回答。
以下是一個例子:呵呵~~
問:Please talk about the history of Book in Print, BIP?
ChatGPT答:
The history of Books in Print (BIP) is closely tied to the evolution of the publishing industry and library services. Here is a brief overview of its development:
Origins and Early History
- 1939: The first edition of Books in Print was published by R.R. Bowker Company, a notable publisher of bibliographic information. This initial edition was a comprehensive directory of all books currently available for sale by publishers in the United States.
- 1940s-1950s: In the following decades, BIP became an essential resource for libraries, booksellers, and publishers. It provided a centralized, reliable source of information on the availability, pricing, and distribution of books.
Expansion and Technological Advancements
- 1960s-1970s: As the number of books published each year continued to grow, the importance of BIP increased. During this period, BIP expanded to include not just current titles but also backlist titles, enhancing its value as a comprehensive reference tool.
- 1980s: The introduction of computer technology began to change the way bibliographic information was managed and accessed. BIP transitioned from a purely print publication to also include electronic formats. This allowed for more frequent updates and easier access to information.
Digital Transformation
- 1990s: The rise of the internet and digital databases brought significant changes. BIP moved online, providing users with instant access to a vast amount of bibliographic data. The online version allowed for more dynamic searches and better integration with other library and bookstore systems.
- 2000s: As digital technologies continued to evolve, BIP expanded its services to include features such as reviews, cover images, and enhanced metadata. This made it a more robust tool for book discovery and collection development.
Modern Era
- 2010s-Present: Today, BIP is a comprehensive, multi-format database that includes information on print books, e-books, audiobooks, and other media. It continues to be an essential tool for librarians, booksellers, publishers, and educators. The modern BIP integrates with library management systems, offering real-time updates and a wide array of search and discovery tools.
Key Milestones
- Collaboration with Libraries: BIP has consistently worked closely with libraries to ensure that its data meets the needs of library professionals. This collaboration has helped maintain its relevance and utility over the decades.
- Integration with Technology: The incorporation of digital tools and online databases has kept BIP at the forefront of bibliographic services, allowing it to adapt to the changing landscape of information technology.
- Expanding Scope: From its beginnings as a print directory of books available for sale, BIP has grown to include a wide range of formats and services, reflecting the diverse ways in which people access and consume books today.
Books in Print remains a cornerstone of bibliographic information, providing an invaluable resource for those involved in the world of books and literature. Its history is a testament to the importance of reliable, comprehensive bibliographic data in supporting the dissemination and discovery of knowledge.
問:那請問RR Bowker創立於哪一年?
ChatGPT答:
R.R. Bowker was founded in 1872. It was established by Frederick Leypoldt, a German immigrant who was a significant figure in the American publishing industry. Leypoldt named the company after Richard Rogers Bowker, his associate and eventual business partner, who was instrumental in developing bibliographic standards and systems that are still influential today. R.R. Bowker has played a crucial role in the publishing world, known for its bibliographic services, including Books in Print.
問:How do you confirm that “ Leypoldt named the company after Richard Rogers Bowker”?
ChatGPT
I apologize for the confusion in my previous message. R.R. Bowker was not named after Richard Rogers Bowker by Frederick Leypoldt; rather, R.R. Bowker is the name of the company founded by Richard Rogers Bowker himself.
Here’s a more accurate account:
Founding of R.R. Bowker
- 1872: Frederick Leypoldt, a German immigrant, founded the company and began publishing trade publications for the book industry, including the publication of bibliographic information.
- 1876: Richard Rogers Bowker, who was an associate of Leypoldt, took over the company after Leypoldt’s death. Bowker continued to expand the company’s focus on bibliographic and library services. The company became known as R.R. Bowker.
R.R. Bowker played a critical role in standardizing and disseminating bibliographic information, making significant contributions to the library and publishing industries, including the establishment of the “Books in Print” directory.
Thank you for pointing out the need for clarification.
問:But Leypoldt did not die until 1884?
ChatGPT答:
You are correct. Frederick Leypoldt did not die until 1884. Here is a revised and accurate account of the founding and history of R.R. Bowker:
Founding and Early History of R.R. Bowker
- 1868: Frederick Leypoldt, a German immigrant and bibliographer, founded “Publishers Weekly,” a trade publication for the book industry, in the United States. His goal was to create a reliable source of bibliographic information for publishers, booksellers, and librarians.
- 1872: Leypoldt also founded “Publishers’ Weekly” (which later became “Publishers Weekly”) and several other bibliographic and trade publications. Around this time, Richard Rogers Bowker joined Leypoldt in his efforts to improve the dissemination of bibliographic information.
- 1876: Richard Rogers Bowker, along with Leypoldt, continued to develop and expand these bibliographic services. They were instrumental in establishing standards and systems that significantly influenced the publishing industry.
- 1880: The company was renamed R.R. Bowker Company to honor Richard Rogers Bowker, who had become a key figure in the company. Leypoldt continued to work with Bowker until his death in 1884.
Role and Impact
R.R. Bowker Company continued to grow under Bowker’s leadership, becoming a leading provider of bibliographic information. It played a crucial role in the development of bibliographic standards and systems, including the introduction of “Books in Print,” which became an essential resource for librarians, booksellers, and publishers.
Conclusion
Frederick Leypoldt and Richard Rogers Bowker both made significant contributions to the field of bibliographic information. Leypoldt’s vision and Bowker’s leadership helped establish R.R. Bowker Company as a cornerstone in the publishing industry, continuing to influence the way bibliographic information is managed and disseminated.
所以事實查核是一個重要的工作,不要完全相信機器人說的,除非能夠自己證實。21世紀在美國的圖書館工作角色中多了一個研究館員(事實查核)research librarian(fact checking)的工作,薪水不錯高於圖書館員平均薪資,和參考館員的薪水差不多。
整體而言,還是謝謝辛苦設計智能機器的研究人員和程式編寫員,智能系統真的越來越好用、越來越親和!